New England Lobster Roll

The salty air hit me first, then the tiny paper boat overflowing with pink lobster meat sitting on a weathered picnic table. I was twelve, somewhere coastal in Maine, and that first bite changed everything about how I thought about summer food. The bread was buttery and toasted just right, holding together sweet chunks of lobster that tasted like the ocean itself. No fancy seasonings, no overwhelming flavors—just perfect simplicity.

My friend Sarah spent a whole summer working at a lobster shack in Cape Cod, and she came back with secrets. She showed me how to toast the rolls in butter instead of just popping them in the toaster, which makes all the difference. We made these for her birthday dinner last year, standing around the kitchen island, eating them standing up because nobody wanted to wait for the table to be set.

Ingredients

• Lobster: Fresh cooked meat from claw, knuckle and tail gives the best mix of textures and sweetness
• Mayonnaise or butter: Mayonnaise makes it classic and creamy while melted butter gives you that Connecticut style warmth
• Lemon juice: Fresh squeezed brightness cuts through the richness and highlights the lobster flavor
• Celery: Optional but adds a nice little crunch that contrasts with the tender meat
• Chives or scallions: Mild onion flavor that complements without overpowering the delicate lobster
• Salt and pepper: Keep it simple, the lobster is the star here
• Split top brioche rolls: The brioche adds richness and the split top lets you toast both sides perfectly
• Butter for toasting: Dont skip this, it transforms the bread into something golden and incredible

Instructions

Prep the lobster mixture:

Gently fold the lobster meat with mayonnaise or melted butter, lemon juice, celery and chives in a medium bowl until just combined. Season carefully with salt and pepper, keeping in mind the lobster should shine through.

Toast the brioche rolls:

Spread softened butter on the outside of each roll and cook them in a skillet over medium heat. Toast for one to two minutes per side until golden brown and crispy.

Assemble the rolls:

Open each toasted roll and pile in the lobster mixture generously. Let it spill over a bit, thats the beauty of a great lobster roll.

Finish and serve:

Top with fresh parsley if you like and serve immediately with lemon wedges on the side for squeezing.

Save to Pinterest

These rolls became our Fourth of July tradition after that first summer. Now nobody asks whats for lunch on the holiday anymore, they just show up with hungry faces and expectant smiles.

Choosing Your Style

New England style uses mayonnaise for a creamy, cold salad that feels incredibly refreshing on hot days. Connecticut style swaps the mayo for warm melted butter, creating a completely different experience thats rich and comforting. Both are worth trying, and most people end up with a strong preference after tasting both side by side.

Getting The Best Lobster

Fresh cooked lobster makes the biggest difference here, so buy from a trusted fish market or seafood counter if possible. If using frozen lobster meat, thaw it completely and pat it dry before mixing to avoid watery rolls. The combination of claw, knuckle and tail meat gives you variety in texture, with the tail being sweetest and the knuckles having the most flavor.

Serving Suggestions

Kettle cooked potato chips are the classic accompaniment, their crunch and salt pairing perfectly with the rich lobster. A simple coleslaw on the side adds freshness and a bit of acidity to balance the meal. Keep the sides simple so they dont compete with the star of the show.

• Old Bay seasoning adds a classic coastal kick if you want extra flavor
• A dash of hot sauce brings gentle heat without overwhelming the lobster
• Try Greek yogurt instead of mayonnaise for a lighter, tangier version

Save to Pinterest

Summer tastes better when you eat with your hands and dont worry about the mess.

Recipe FAQs

→ What's the difference between New England and Connecticut style lobster rolls?

New England style features lobster meat mixed with mayonnaise, while Connecticut style uses warm melted butter instead. Both are served on toasted buttery rolls.

→ Can I use frozen lobster meat?

Yes, frozen cooked lobster meat works well. Thaw it completely in the refrigerator and pat dry before using to prevent the dressing from becoming watery.

→ What type of rolls work best?

Split-top brioche rolls or New England-style hot dog buns are traditional. Their shape holds the lobster perfectly and toasts beautifully on the sides.

→ How long will prepared lobster meat keep?

The dressed lobster mixture is best enjoyed immediately but can be refrigerated for up to 1 day. Toast the rolls fresh before serving.

→ Can I make this ahead of time for a party?

Prepare the lobster mixture up to 4 hours ahead and refrigerate. Toast the brioche rolls just before serving to maintain their crisp texture.